Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Fuck James Dolan


I’ve been lulled out of my journalistic coma by a blind rage caused by the Knick’s decision to let Jeremy Lin walk to the Houston Rockets, either out of spite or some misguided sense of fiscal responsibility. Of course, Lin was a popular topic on this forum as he set the hoops world on fire with a remarkable string of games that elevated him from benchwarmer to superstar.

And now he’s gone.

The contract offered to Lin is a little ridiculous for a relatively unproven player, but the Knicks are so hamstrung with their ability to add players that failing to retain a guy, who at the very least could be an effective scorer off the bench or tradable asset, is infuriating. My anger is less about Lin, who I still believe to be a good player, and more about the radical ineptness of the Knicks. The Knicks owner, for the less diehard amongst us, is James Dolan. Dolan is the scion of the Cablevision empire, who took over the team from his father and subsequently led them down a road to perdition littered with bad contracts and untalented players.

Dolan is universally loathed, except by the management of opposing teams who are eager to fleece him, and players and agents who know a sucker when they see one. He’s the product of nepotism, a recovering drug addict and aspiring blues musician who’s never been told “no.” Supposedly, he values loyalty above all other traits and the Knicks have turned into a weird sort of cult under his rule. The team is notoriously tight lipped and Dolan’s voice is only heard when he awkwardly croons terrible blues ballads.

And yet, you couldn’t say he didn’t try. Dolan spent freely, if stupidly. He spared no expense, be it overpaying for the mercurial Larry Brown or the always-ravished Eddy Curry. He even covered a tort assessed for Isiah Thomas’s alleged sexual harassment of a Knicks official. That’s why consternation over Jeremy Lin’s “poison pill” contract rings so hollow.  With his team on the brink of quasi-contender status, he’s now decided to be fiscally responsible?

Other reports say that Dolan got into a petty pissing match because Lin renegotiated his contract with the Rockets after Knicks’ sources leaked that they would match any contract up to  “a billion dollars.”  Boo-fucking-hoo Dolan, don’t tip your hand. Why the media shy Knicks felt that the Lin contract was a good time to start being more free with access boggles the mind.

Even more upsetting is that all of this was done under the context of the Knicks trying to reach Finals. They signed role players like the ancient Marcus Camby and Jason Kidd as well as the one dimensional Steve Novak to expensive and long contracts. But now they’ve decided to roll the dice with Raymond Felton, last seen in a Portland McDonalds trying to “supersize” his French fries, instead of the dynamic Lin.

An upsetting by product is that this move will leave a lot of people misguidedly upset with Felton. Felton had a brief run with the Knicks in 2010-11, when he proved himself to be a warrior and fan favorite before he was jettisoned in the controversial Carmelo Anthony trade. Now Felton will be inextricably linked to the loss of Lin and will likely become a pariah.

Some have compared this to the Mets failure to resign Jose Reyes this offseason, but it feels a lot worse to me. The Mets financial troubles were well documented and the team was projected to be bad with or without Reyes. The Knicks fancy themselves to be contenders and let a valuable player walk for nothing.

Yesterday I was struck with a feeling of helplessness. As the three day window to match closed, I took to Twitter and, like many Knicks fans, let loose a stream of vitriol and obscenity directed at James Dolan, and it was ineffective and un-cathartic.

I’ve disagreed with almost every move the Knicks have made this offseason, as they’ve gotten older and less athletic, but that’s nothing new. I’ve long been a Knicks apologist, I gave Isiah Thomas the benefit of the doubt again and again because at least it seemed like he was trying to build a good team. I enjoyed rooting for Othella Harrington and Michael Sweetney and Michael Doleac and Eddy Curry and Stephon Marbury and Keith Van Horn and all the other inglorious bastards to wear a Knicks uniform this past decade.

My rage at the Knicks comes at an interesting time. I’ve just moved to Brooklyn and simultaneously so have the Nets. The Nets have been a little Knicks-esque with their fetishization of big name players, but at least their owner isn’t a Kim Jung Un like leader, who’s management of the Knicks matches his tone-deafness as the lead singer of JD and the Straight Shot. The internet has been abuzz with sports pundits giving me cart-blanche to switch my allegiances. So what do I do? I’m not ready to root for the Nets, but I’m just about ready to stop rooting for the Knicks.

5 comments:

  1. See this is kind of ridiculous to me. We bash the Knicks for never being fiscally responsible, but as soon as they make a decision that can be considered that, we bash them anyway. All you have to do is let go of the rosy retrospection and actually look at the games and the skill set and realize that he's not great, he probably won't be, and there really is no reason besides getting Asian revenue that you sign this man. Lin had a couple of good games before the scouting reports were in against subpar teams (barring the lakers, who might have had the worst defensive PG tandem in Fisher and Steve Blake) but any time he played a remotely decent PG he got destroyed. Look what Deron did to him the next time they played. He obliterated him. Mario fucking Chalmers had him looking like a 12 year old playing against grown men. Even in his best games his turnover to assist ratio is absolutely HORRENDOUS. He's a small scoring two guard, at best. HIs pick and roll ability only looked good because A) playing with tyson chandler B) the only other players we had to compare him to was a rookie Shump just learning the position and Toney 'Disaster' Douglas. And from a basketball standpoint, we need another scorer who needs to have the basketball in their hands like we need Jr Smith to keep shooting. To add to this, he's coming off of a knee injury? Good luck to him, but why the hell do we need to take the risk, especially at that amount of money? It baffles me. Felton was playing at an all-star level when he was last with us. He was on a portland team that had a log jam at PG and left him dissatisfied with no playing time. Amare is excited to have him back, and he had one of his best years ever with him. And no one would possibly argue that we need Jeremy Lin to perform more than we do Amare. Add Jason Kidd, as much as I hate the guy, anchoring our second unit with shooters like JR and Novak, running the PnR with Tyson or Amare, and we have a team that is solid as is. So in conclusion, Jeremy Lin is no longer a Knick, so fuck him, and lets stop acting like he deserved his jersey on the rafters for performing against subpar .500 teams. And saying you're going to stop rooting for the knicks for probably their soundest decision in the last 5 years, is pretty foolish. If you want to Nets front run, just do that. Don't use Lin and pretend that's a legitimate excuse.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 1. The move was only fiscally sound from the perspective of James Dolans wallet, not signing Lin leaves them in the same place they wouldve been as signing him-they won't be able to add players via signing or sign and trades regardless.

      2. Even if Lin was the 9th guy in the rotation, and I don't believe Lin was that great by any means, it's still worth it to sign him given the fact that he's 23 and we can't add any more players of substance.

      3. The nets will be worse than the Knicks next year, it's not front running, I just don't want James Dolan making decisions that affect my happiness.

      Delete
    2. Jamaine, most of the shit you said is pretty smart and is a sound argument, however, the other side of the argument is smart and sound too. The one thing that should be most important though, is that Lin was just about the most exciting thing regarding the Knicks since at least the 99, and arguably dating back much much further. While I agree that stupid contracts in the past shouldn't justify the Knicks continuing to hand them out, this contract wasn't that stupid considering what Jonah said, that it wasn't like it was Lin or someone else, it was Lin or no one else. And the bad contract argument isn't presented to justify that he knicks should keep signing bad contracts, it is there to prove that Dolan didn't let Lin go because of money, he let him go out of spite, which is a joke. I really agree with you about the "he's gone. fuck him" sentiment, but somewhere deep down I'm rooting for him to succeed to further prove how assbackwards everything Dolan does is. Also, most true Knicks fans won't go over to the Nets, but like Jonah said, when Lin was let go, we felt helpless and hopeless, so the Nets option is giving fans a legitimate and seemingly viable way to show their dissatisfaction with the team.

      Clearly you're coming from a place of a true knicks fan, but at the same time you're sounding like a battered wife who is justifying their relationship despite all the signs that it's toxic. I, like you, will remain a life loyal knicks fan, but lets not pretend like we fell down the stairs when we just got punched in the face.

      Delete
  2. ok, idk if your asian, but jeremy lin winning 8 regular games against sub 500 teams is not the best thing to happen to the knicks in the last 12 years. us winning a play off game is. is it the most sensationalized? yeah, no doubt. but a great story should stay that, a great story. but the truth is the dude is a turnover machine with no real point guard ability so i don't get how he's going to push this team forward at all. i realized this a fact when he couldnt beat a one man mario chalmers press. mario chalmers. we need an actual pg, and you can clown felton for this season but in the same d'antoni system that is probably the real reason for lins success, he put up wayyy better numbers and played great with amare and he's excited to have him back. we know what felton will give us, and thats enough of a reason to get him.

    and dont worry, i know i love the knicks and they don't love me back, but im all in in this relationship.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jay - Of players last year with at least 300 posessions, Lin ranked 252 in turnovers. So not that good. Guess who ranked 256th and 258th respectively? Rondo and Nash. Turnovers in the flow of an agressive passing game should be expected. he scored 38 against the Lakers. He saved the knicks season. he plays hard as shit. He made this kick ass video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L4cPG1Dmh2I - and inspired this one - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zExrVyTX_aw

    Jamaine - Why the f do you care about trust fund baby/moron Dolan being fiscally responsible? The contract would have had little to no neg impact on the Knicks as a team. You can often unload expiring contracts in their last year, and they cant spend the money they save on lin on anyone else. The only impact is on fat/bad singer Dolan's wallet, and he never "worked" a day in his stupid life to fill said wallet.

    Either you guys don't understand basketball, or are suffering from knicks self-disillusionalment. Its a real disease....the only known cure....NETS nets nets nets!

    Fuck you Dolan.

    ReplyDelete